Article published – Worker deaugmentation risk in tourism and hospitality automation: evidence from a back-of-the-house occupation

Two main effects of technology on employment are usually identified: job replacement and job augmentation. Augmentation occurs when technology enhances human capabilities, enabling people to improve their innate abilities. In other words, technology gives humans greater analytical capabilities, more memory, greater physical strength, or the ability to perceive signals that would otherwise be imperceptible.

Recently, my colleague Santiago Melián and I published an article explaining another possible effect of technology that has not previously been identified: worker deaugmentation. This effect occurs when technology performs the important and valuable tasks of a job, leaving humans to carry out less rewarding activities. For example, consider a robot capable of cooking dishes but requiring humans to supply it with chopped vegetables, refill its sauce containers, or clean its work area. All these tasks are less valuable and less rewarding than actually cooking the dish.

The article, entitled “Worker deaugmentation risk in tourism and hospitality automation: evidence from a back-of-the-house occupation,” has been published in Current Issues in Tourism (Q1, ranked 25th out of 141 journals in the Tourism category). The article is available at https://doi.org/10.1080/13683500.2026.2748544 (the final published version is not available open access). Alternatively, a pre-publication version can be accessed through the ULPGC repository: https://accedacris.ulpgc.es/handle/10553/271216.

This is the abstract: El resumen del trabajo es el siguiente: Worker augmentation dominates current narratives about robotics and AI. These technologies may, however, also produce worker deaugmentation, which occurs when technology automates the tasks employees value most while leaving them responsible for lower-value, monotonous activities. This letter introduces worker deaugmentation, argues that it is particularly relevant in tourism and hospitality, where occupations combine diverse manual and cognitive tasks, and advances two propositions. We illustrate them in a back-of-the-house occupation, rating the 14 core tasks O*NET assigns to the cook occupation, evaluating each according to its subjective value and likelihood of automation. Expert assessments indicate that seven support the deaugmentation effect: five highly valued tasks are highly automatable, whereas two low-value tasks appear resistant to automation. These findings suggest that automation may reduce job quality and intrinsic motivation. A two-by-two framework distinguishes deaugmentation risk from beneficial automation and indicates where job design should intervene.

Published article – Tourism positively impacts the well-being of residents

(Image by Jakub Zerdzicki, Pexels)

Santiago Melián, Sara González Betancor and I have published an article titled “Impacts of tourism associated with residents’ well-being: an analysis in 197 European OECD regions” in the journal Tourism Review (Q1 & D1 of JCR). The article is open access and is available at: https://doi.org/10.1108/TR-10-2024-0924.

ABSTRACT: This article examines the relationship between tourism development and residents’ well-being in 197 regions across 21 European countries. Using the OECD’s framework, it explores how tourism is associated with eleven dimensions of well-being, both subjective and objective. The findings show that, overall, greater tourism development is linked to higher levels of well-being, particularly in industrial regions and those with economies based on the primary or service sectors. In contrast, in regions with quinary economies—such as those focused on education, health, or public administration—the association is weaker. The only well-being indicator that shows a negative relationship with tourism is civic engagement in primary-based regions. A limitation of this study is the lack of longitudinal data for well-being indicators, which prevents establishing causal relationships. Nevertheless, the research provides valuable evidence for policymaking, highlighting tourism’s potential to drive development and improve quality of life. The study also stands out for its methodological approach, using overnight stays—not just arrivals—as a measure of tourism activity, and for its broad territorial scope, which is still rare in the literature on this topic.

Published article – Is tourism development associated with employment of low quality?

Is tourism development associated with employment of low quality?

Purpose
The purpose of this study is to analyze whether higher tourism development in a region is associated with lower-quality employment in that region.

Design/methodology/approach
The analysis is based on the last two editions of the European Working Conditions Survey and on the tourism development of European regions. Two samples were studied (2015 and 2021).

Findings
Tourism development does not affect the quality of employment in regions. The institutional regime of the country to which the region belongs is associated with the job quality (JQ) in the region.

Research limitations/implications
Only subjective indicators of employment quality are considered in the analysis.

Practical implications
The quality of employment is related to the institutional regime. Policymakers should consider the institutional factors of social democratic countries to improve the low quality of tourism occupations.

Originality/value
Research on the quality of employment in tourism has mostly focused on tourism occupations without considering determinants other than industry characteristics. This research is unique because it includes both the institutional view of JQ and the overall regional employment.

Artificial intelligence’s impact on hospitality and tourism marketing: exploring key themes and addressing challenges (published article)

The article “Artificial intelligence’s impact on hospitality and tourism marketing: exploring key themes and addressing challenges” has been published in Current Issues of Tourism (Q1 of JCR). It is available Open Access. Its authors are Jacques Bulchand-Gidumal, Edu William, Peter O’Connor y Dimitrios Buhalis.

Abstract:

Understanding how Artificial Intelligence (AI) impacts organizational functions supports stakeholders to prepare accordingly and profit from these developments. Adopting a grounded theory approach, this study uses three interlinked stages (in-depth interviews, focus groups and a questionnaire-based survey) to explore the impact of AI on the marketing function of hotels. The results identify ten trends related to AI’s contribution to hotel marketing, clustered in four themes. AI reengineers internal processes and procedures by enabling data and content as catalysts of competitiveness; empowering the augmented worker and performing mass personalization and customization. AI also impacts relationships with stakeholders by determining return on investment; improving sustainability; and governing legal aspects and ethics regarding data use. AI supports networks to which the organizations belong by concentrating and integrating organizations and transforming distribution models. AI transforms customer processes and services by engaging smart and predictive customer care and by employing predictive and augmented product and service design. The study illustrates the changes that AI will likely bring to hospitality and tourism marketing, developing a research agenda and raising discussion points for academic and industry practitioners respectively.

The case of BeReal and spontaneous online social networks and their impact on tourism: research agenda (published article)

The article “The case of BeReal and spontaneous online social networks and their impact on tourism: research agenda” has been published in Current Issues of Tourism (Q2 del JCR).

Abstract: The importance of online social networks (OSN) in tourism has been well documented in the literature. Most OSN share common characteristics. One of them is allowing users and companies to extensively plan and edit their posts. Recently, a new type of OSN has emerged: spontaneous online social networks (SOSN). These SOSN can be stand-alone products (e.g. BeReal) or features added to existing OSN. This research note provides an initial approach to SOSN and how they may change the dynamics of travellers and tourism companies. It provides a research agenda concerning the growth of SOSN.

Awarded the Journal Paper of the Year for papers published in 2019

Entrega del premio

At the ENTER2020 congress, held in Surrey from January 8 to 10, 2020, Santiago Melíán and myself were awarded the prize for the best scientific article published in 2019 in the area of tourism and technology. The award refers to the publication “Why are ratings so high in the sharing economy? Evidence based on guest perspectives” published in Current Issues in Tourism (located in the first quartile of the JCR) and written by myself and Santiago Melian. In this previous post on the blog I briefly explain the content of that article.

The ENTER2020 congress was organized by IFITT (International Federation for IT and Travel & Tourism), the worldwide organization that brings together all researchers in the area of tourism and technology.

A model that connects information technology and hotel performance (paper published)

Detailed model
Despite vast investments in IT, there is scant research and empirical data that connects, in depth, IT with firm performance in the hospitality industry. However, the literature does show partial evidence and examples of particular technologies. After an extensive literature review, we posit four global paths through which IT can impact hotel performance and, for each one, the precise mechanisms that cause these influences. These four proposals are further developed and refined using in-depth interviews with a group of 30 managers of different areas from several hotels. A final comprehensive model that shows the specific routes that IT can follow in order to improve hotel organizational performance is presented. This model can be taken as a frame of reference by academics and can also be used by both practitioners and IT producers to assess particular IT options.

The article entitled A model that connects information technology and hotel performance was published in Tourism Management (impact index: 2,6) in April 2016.

Second economy in tourism: Jobs and IT (paper published)

Journal: PASOS, Journal of Tourism and Cultural Heritage

Paper title: Second economy in tourism: Jobs and IT

Authors: Santiago Melián-González, Jacques Bulchand-Gidumal

Abstract: In general society has assumed the huge presence of information and communication technology (ICT) in all life’s facets. Nevertheless, this technology penetration may be substituting organizations’ occupations. Automation phenomenon has been mainly studied in the industrial activity, but it is a wider trend due to the technological development. Although the tourism industry has been pioneer in ICT utilization there are no works about its impact on tourism jobs. After a revision of the literature on how ICT influence jobs, and an analysis of the job posts in hotels in Spain, this article is a basic approach to this question and pretends to be a reflection about the use of ICT by tourism firms. The trend found points to a significant impact of ICT on the quantity and type of work currently done in tourism activities.

ISSN: 1695-7121

Keywords: auto service, employment, occupations, human resources, technology

 

New evidence of the relationship between employee satisfaction and firm economic performance (paper published)

satisfied workerWith my colleagues Santiago Melián and Beatriz López Gónzález-Valcárcel, we have just published in the journal Personnel Review that belongs to Emerald the paper titled “New evidence of the relationship between employee satisfaction and firm economic performance“.

This is the structured abstract:

Purpose. Employee satisfaction appears in any discussion about how employees can contribute to organizational performance. The purpose of this paper is to test the relationship between employee satisfaction and organizational performance; this later measured with three firm-level performance outcomes (return over assets, operating margin, and revenue per employee).

Design/methodology/approach. At different times and from two independent sources the authors obtained firms’ data about worker attitudes and financial and productivity performance, respectively. The analyzed sample of 475 firms is the biggest among the studies that analyze performance and employee satisfaction at the firm level. The impact of employee satisfaction over firm performance was assessed.

Findings. Overall satisfaction and satisfaction with senior leadership, compensation, and work/life balance, respectively impact firm performance.

Research limitations/implications. The ratings come from both employees and ex-employees and the individual characteristics were unknown. Additionally as an internet-based sample there has been a lack of control over the individuals’ response process.

Practical implications. Managers have evidence about the importance of their employees’ satisfaction on firm performance, and on how the facets involved on worker satisfaction impact the performance.

Social implications. Employer review web sites are increasing their popularity. However, unlike the marketing field with consumers HR area has not taken advantage of this trend. The found results may contribute to highlight the importance of this kind of data.

Originality/value. Hitherto there is only one empirical evidence about the positive role of worker satisfaction in objective and financial firm level performance. That was based in best-firms type data. The current study draws in a big sample independent of this kind of rankings. Additionally, the job facet satisfaction conceptualization considered demonstrates the usefulness of this way to understand the employee satisfaction.

(photo by Happy Business Worker , Flickr)

weWOM: A new type of word of mouth (paper published)

grupo de trabajadoresMy collegue Santiago Melián González and myseft have just published in the journal Universia Business Review an article named “Worker eWOM: los trabajadores opinan en Internet“ (the article is in Spanish).

Starting with eWOM (electronic word-of-mouth), that has already been widely analyzed, we describe a similar behaviour, that is starting to be relevant and that has not been dealed with up to now. We have named it weWOM (worker electronic word-of-mouth) and it consists on the fact that employees and ex-employees of companies, on their own initiative, rate and review their companies as a place to work. There are several websites specificaly dedicated to this type of behaviour, being GlassDoor the one that stands out. In this paper, we describe weWOM, the places in which it may be found, and the consequences and implications it may have for organizations.

(picture by Dave Coller, Flickr)